Privacy and You

 
Living a private life is a difficult choice in today's society where social media and the internet are being utilized every second of the day. Metadata is constantly being collected based on what articles you read and what links you click. Providing a digital snapshot of you and your online interests and hobbies. A recent article from Simon Kemp on Data Reportal states that a typical internet user spends almost 2 and a half hours on social media platforms per day. At an average of 143 minutes per day, per user, the world spends 720 billion minutes per day using social platforms. Over a full year, that adds up to more than 260 trillion minutes, or 500 million years of collective human time. (Kemp, 2024)

Photo Source: Data Reportal

That is a lot of our time on social media platforms but the real topic of privacy starts before you even finalize creating your account with the provider's Terms of Service. Terms of Service are an agreement between you the user, and the service provider. These can be legally binding and shocking if you do not read the fine print. The app makers know better than to bold anything or make anything clear — especially about how your actions will morph into marketing metadata, sprinkling a trail of “cookies” behind you. (Zomorodi, 2017) Ultimately, the question is, how badly do you want to use their site or platform and do you understand the data you are giving away when agreeing to their Terms of Service?

In a Pew Research Center study based on a survey of 461 U.S. adults and nine online focus groups of 80 people finds that there are a variety of circumstances under which many Americans would share personal information or permit surveillance in return for getting something of perceived value. While many Americans are willing to share personal information in exchange for tangible benefits, they are often cautious about disclosing their information and frequently unhappy about what happens to that information once companies have collected it. (Rainie & Duggan, 2016) Many times how organizations plan to use their data is outlined in a Terms of Service agreement, a privacy policy, or a confidentiality policy. Sure, it may seem easier to just scroll to the bottom and hit accept, but do you really know and understand what you are agreeing to and where this data is going next?

When doing a review of the Terms of Service for popular streaming service, Twitch, I discovered there are many phrases buried within the agreement that could cause concern for users and raises the question of if they know what they are truly signing up for when agreeing to use this platform. It includes quotes like, "All Materials are the property of Twitch or its subsidiaries or affiliated companies and/or third-party licensors" and "Your use of the Twitch Services is at your own risk." These small statements can easily be missed if a user is skimming the Terms of Service and could be used later to solely benefit Twitch without providing reparation to the creator of that content.

Privacy in Libraries

Libraries in the United States actively work to provide privacy to their users. The American Library Association (ALA) which many libraries use as a tool and guide when writing policies believe library users have the right to privacy, freedom to read, and freedom to view materials they choose without repercussions. All people, regardless of origin, age, background, or views, possess a right to privacy and confidentiality in their library use. When users recognize or fear that their privacy or confidentiality is compromised, true freedom of inquiry no longer exists. Privacy is essential to free inquiry in the library because it enables library users to select, access, and consider information and ideas without fear of embarrassment, judgment, punishment, or ostracism. (ALA, 2021) Users should not have fear that if they access something for personal, professional, or academic reference that it would be shared to other organizations, third-parties, or even law enforcement without going through proper channels supported by law.


Photo Source: ALA Advocacy/Privacy


Many libraries have privacy policies that their users can reference on their websites. Privacy policies are like Terms of Service agreements, they vary by company or organization. Some libraries combine their policies on privacy and confidentiality and some keep them separate. When using a public entity like a library it is important to know what rights you have and how these rights are being protected. 

It is important to note that libraries do use third-party providers to support their users and provide them access to resources and databases. Oak Park Public Library does a great job listing the Third-Parties they use in their Data Privacy policy. Naperville Public Library mentions the use of Third-Parties in their Confidentiality and Privacy policy and encourages their users to read through the provider's Terms of Service or Conditions before using them. Aurora Public Library mentions in their Privacy Notice that they use a Third-Party they may share users data with to retrieve fines and fees. They also mention that there may be links to outside organizations which they do not control the content, claiming it does not mean they endorse the content on the external site. These warnings are helpful to users but it is still up to the individual to ensure they are doing their due diligence prior to using these providers.

Conclusion

Not everyone on the internet or mobile apps are out to get you, but it is important to read the fine print for users to understand how their data is being collected, stored, and used. Companies and providers tend to make these mandatory prior to you using their sites or content. It is up to the user to take the time to read through, ask questions, and seek answers before they blindly agree to use a service or provider. By thoroughly reading these Policies, Terms of Service and/or Conditions a user can make an educated decision on if this aligns to how they would like their data collected, stored, and used.

References:

ALA. (2021). Privacy. ALA

ALA. (2019). Privacy: An Interpretation of the Library Bill of Rights. ALA.

Aurora Public Library. (n/d). Privacy Notice. Aurora Public Library.

Kemp, S. (2024). The Time We Spend on Social Media. Data Reportal.

Naperville Public Library. (2023). Confidentiality and Privacy Policy. Naperville Public Library.

Oak Park Public Library. (n/d). Data Privacy. Oak Park Public Library.

Rainie, L. & Duggan, M. (2016). Privacy and Information Sharing. Pew Research Center.

Twitch. (2023). Terms of Service. Twitch Interactive, Inc.

Zomorodi, M. (2017). Do You Know How Much Private Information You Give Away Every Day?. Time.

Comments

  1. It's great to see there are some public libraries out there that are setting a positive example for other entities when it comes to privacy. It's a full time job to keep up with and most of us (me included) too easily click "accept" without really understanding what we are giving up.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Jenny, It's wild to think just how much of an effort one needs to put in order to obtain true privacy these days, feels like one must take a pilgrimage to a remote landscape to limit the harvesting of our data and private information. The statistics of average screen times that you shared are alarming! Yet, it doesn't feel all that consuming and that is how they get you! A while ago I used to work at a company for logistics and they banned us from brining in our phones into the facility during our shifts, and although it was troublesome and annoying to be disconnected from my phone during work, it drastically reduced my level of stress. There was something almost comforting about knowing that I would be disconnected from everything for a short period. I wonder if abstaining from our phones and internet for short periods at regular intervals can benefit us?

    I hadn't really thought about how libraries protect the privacy of their patrons and I am glad that they are taking the steps in doing so! How do you strike a balance between sharing valuable insights and safeguarding your own privacy?

    Thanks for sharing!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Joel, I feel like you're not far off with having to be off the grid to truly disconnect. Not many people would be comfortable being separated from their devices for a even a quick run to the store, let alone a whole work day. Last summer when visiting my cousin, my husband and I both left our phones at their place and they commented on how we are crazy and they could never do that... I relate to you that when I am not around my phone and receiving constant updates, my stress levels are reduced.

      You raise an interesting question about taking breaks, even if they are short, from our phones or the internet could be beneficial. I would have to think so. There are studies out there that show by keeping cell phones in your bedroom at night can be quite distracting and actually make people's sleep schedules worse. This is particularly true with teenagers but many parents cannot model this behavior easily either.

      As for libraries, they are amazing resources to connect people with information and services. Privacy is at the top of mind when collecting and storing user information including what materials they check out. Overall, the users privacy takes priority. It is only shared with authorities such as law enforcement in critical situations such as immediate danger to that person. Otherwise, they can follow proper channels to request data such as warrants and the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). Public libraries are public. Therefore there are rights that users have and they can request information as well.

      I hope that helps answer your questions!
      Thanks,
      Jenny

      Delete
    2. Hey Jenny,

      Yes this does indeed answer my question! Thanks for the response!

      Delete
  3. Hi Jennifer,

    I enjoyed reading your blog post! I found the bar graph you included on social media usage in hours and minutes for January 2024 particularly interesting. I'm curious if the number of hours and minutes spent on social media platforms is higher in colder months than warmer months because of time spent indoors? I was also intrigued by your perspective on online privacy as a librarian. Similar to students in schools, library patrons should not have to fear that their personal data will be shared with other organizations, third parties, or even law enforcement. After reading your post, I have a much better understanding of the online privacy rights I have at the library and how these rights are being protected.

    Thank you for sharing,
    Emily

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Emily - I would be interested too about the data in colder months or even for months that have rainy weather. Does that play a role in the increase because of the being trapped indoors or does it stay the same ? Has being on our devices just become a thing that we have all integrated into our daily routines/become addicted to using daily.....

      Delete
    2. Hi Emily, I would have to imagine there is a spike in some areas during colder periods of the year. I read while researching that Canada actually uses social media less than all of the other countries that they collected data from and they tend to have a colder climate. This would be very neat if they tracked it on a more local scale, even if it was just within the United States to see when using social media is the most popular per state. I'm so happy this provided you with more insight on how your information is being protected when you use your local library!

      Thank you,
      Jenny

      Delete
  4. Jennifer - I really enjoyed reading your blog. The data you shared regarding the amount of time online is crazy....but with a lot of it right at our fingertips on our phones and other devices the data doesn't surprise me too much. As well as so many people always creating "content" or documenting their lives to post on social media perhaps has added to the increase of use. You also brought a good point that providers in their Term of Use know that they shouldn't bold/italicize (calling attention to it) information that might defer the user from agreeing to their terms. Your post gave a great insight to online privacy and breadcrumbs that can be left behind. Before your post I hadn't really thought of libraries and privacy associated with their users. It is nice to know that they are taking the necessary steps to help protect their privacy and one can go there and knowing it is being protected. Great post!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Kristen, Thank you for your reflection! I was also shocked when I saw this information that the average person is on social media for about 2 and a half hours a day. When we think about on a global scale it blows my mind. I am glad I could share some background about privacy in libraries and what rights you have a public library user. We're fighting the good fight in the library world even though sometimes it feels like an up-hill battle.

      Thanks again,
      Jenny

      Delete
  5. Jenny,

    I could not get over how many man hours are spent each day just looking at social media. I can only imagine what that time could be used for and the impact that would have on society. I really liked you dive into the Terms of Service as that is a new thing I have started to be more aware of with this class as well as a library lesson my students had the other week. I wonder has reading any of this changed the way you use the Internet? I know it has not changed anything for me though I know it should.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Kevin, I am actually overall a pretty private internet user. This blog and testing new ways to create content while completing my Master's degree has pushed me to a new place of usage. I haven't deviated greatly, but by diving deeper into the idea of privacy and metadata it has made me even more cautious before clicking agree without reading what I am agreeing to first.

      Thank you for your reflection!
      Jenny

      Delete
  6. WOW! That first statistic blew my mind. As a frequent social media scroller, I spend less time during the week, but on weekends I find myself scrolling more than I should. I loved hearing the point of view from a library that you provided. It sounds like they try to provide the best security to their users even through a third party. I will say that generally I do not read the terms of use as I should. However, after this week and reading more I think I should be more cautious of what media I use! Thanks for sharing your insight.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts